Trial of a Thousand Years: World Order and Islamism (Hoover Institution Press Publication) (Volume 607) - Hardcover

“A Muslim has no nationality except his religious beliefs,” said Egyptian Sayyid Qutb, a key figure in the world of political Islam who was executed by the secular regime in his homeland in 1966. For the Islamists, the normal diplomatic order, constructed by unbelievers and accepted by state regimes across the Arab Islamic world, is no order of theirs. In this book, Charles Hill presents a detailed historical perspective on the assault of Islamism against the order of states.

To understand the current Islamist assault on world order, says the author, it is necessary to recognize that every major war of the modern age has been an ideologically driven attempt—no two alike—to overthrow and replace the Westphalian international state system. Each war, he shows, sheds light on the question of world order and Islamism. He explains, for example, how, with the defeat and final exile of Napoleon in 1815, the French Revolution’s immediate threat to the international system was ended, but how its ideology would continue to live in later times and places, not least in the Middle East. Moving through history all the way to the cold war, he documents how the Soviets realized that they could exploit Arab discontent with the state system. And he reveals more of the vicissitudes of cold war era diplomacy in the story of Iran, which maneuvered its way through the troubles of the twentieth century—colonial exploitation, war, and revolution—to be in, but never of, the international system.

He concludes that America must not give up its values; neither should it retreat by practicing them only at home or by telling ourselves that our values are no more worthy than any others selected at random from the world’s many cultures. The first step, he says, is to recognize the problem and then try to develop ways to deal with the exploitation of asymmetries by the enemies of world order. From the global point of view, the stakes are enormous.

The challenge that Islamists pose for world order

The Islamist war on the international state system

The Islamist war on world order

For decades, the ideologues of pan-Islam have refused to accept the boundaries and the responsibilities of the order of states. In Trial of a Thousand Years, Charles Hill analyzes the long war of Islamism against the international state system. Hill places the Islamists in their proper historical place, showing that they are but the latest challenge to the requirements that states had placed on themselves since the international system was born in 1648.

The author describes the many wars on the world order over the centuries--the French Revolution and Napoleonic Wars, World Wars I and II, the cold war—and gives a unique historical perspective to the Islamic challenge of the twenty-first century in Iran, Afghanistan, and beyond. He identifies the key areas in which the Islamists are at odds with the rest of the world—legal, military, the state, women, democracy, nuclear weapons, and values—and tells what the United States, as the chief protector of world order, must do to deal effectively with the adversaries of the international system.

Charles Hill, a career minister in the U.S. Foreign Service, is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution. Hill was executive aide to former U.S. secretary of state George P. Shultz (1985–89) and served as special consultant on policy to the secretary-general of the United Nations from 1992 to 1996. He is also the Brady-Johnson Distinguished Fellow in Grand Strategy and Senior Lecturer in International Studies and in Humanities at Yale University.